German theologians blast Benedict’s letter as ‘failed and improper’ account of abuse crisis

A group of prominent German-speaking theologians has sharply criticized retired Pope Benedict XVI’s recent letter on clergy sexual abuse, saying it “instrumentalized” the Catholic Church’s continuing crisis to rehash stale, decades-long theological disputes.

In a blunt two-page letter released on April 15, the theologians said the former pontiff ignored scientific research on the causes of abuse, neglected evidence of the centuries-long history of the problem, and did not speak from the perspective of victim-survivors.

“The analysis of Joseph Ratzinger/Benedict XVI is based on a number of false assumptions,” said the German Association of Moral Theologians, which represents about 40 prominent academics. “It is assessed by us as a failed and improper contribution to the resolution of the abuse crisis.”

In his letter, released on April 11, Benedict had partially blamed the abuse crisis on developments in theology following the Second Vatican Council. The ex-pope alleged that there had been a “collapse” in moral theology in recent decades that left the church “defenseless” against changes in wider society, and even identified two German theologians by name.

The letter, one of a handful Benedict has shared publicly since his resignation in 2013, immediately drew criticism from Vatican watchers. They noted, it did not address structural issues that abetted abuse cover-up, or Benedict’s own contested 24-year role as head of the Vatican’s powerful doctrinal office.

Prominent U.S. theologians also expressed concern that Benedict’s action risked undermining Pope Francis’ efforts to address clergy abuse and played into narratives splitting Catholics between two Popes.

In their April 15 response, the German theologians said, they felt compelled to comment on Benedict’s letter because it was a “reproach and insult to the reputations of former and current members” of their association.

Easter party cuts across religious divide in India

Some 3,000 people including Hindus, Muslims and Sikhs joined Christians this year in celebrating Easter at an event in central India’s Bhopal city aimed at promoting religious tolerance.

Archbishop Leo Cornelio of Bhopal was the main organizer of the inter-religious gathering in the capital of Madhya Pradesh State on Easter Sunday.

“Religious fanaticism is not restricted to one country, but has now become a major concern for peace-loving people across the globe, irrespective of their religion,” he told the gathering.

Benefit concert for Notre-Dame Cathedral

An organist from Notre-Dame Cathedral performed a benefit concert in Washington for the reconstruction of the iconic Parisian Church. He ended his program, fittingly, with a piece about Christ’s resurrection.

The concert at the Basilica of the National Shrine of the Immaculate Conception is free and open to the public with a free-will offering to help repair the cathedral that was severely damaged in the April 15 fire.

Police official: Short-circuit likely caused Notre-Dame fire

Paris police investigators think an electrical short-circuit most likely caused the fire at Notre-Dame Cathedral, a police official said on April 18 , as France paid a daylong tribute to the firefighters who saved the world-renowned landmark.

A judicial police official told The Associated Press that investigators made an initial assessment of the cathedral Wednesday but don’t have a green light to search Notre on Dame’s charred interior because of ongoing safety hazards.

The cathedral’s fragile walls were being shored up with wooden planks, said the official, who spoke on condition of anonymity because he wasn’t authorized to speak by name about an ongoing investigation.

Investigators so far believe the fire was accidental, and are questioning both cathedral staff and workers who were carrying out renovations. Some 40 people had been questioned by, according to the Paris prosecutor’s office.

Fire chaplain helped to save religious artefacts from burning cathedral

A hero emerging from the Notre-Dame Cathedral fire on April 15 was Father Jean-Marc Fournier, chaplain of the Paris Fire Brigade, who is credited with saving a reliquary containing the crown of thorns and the Blessed Sacrament from the burning cathedral. “Father Fournier is an absolute hero,” a member of the Paris fire department told reporters on April 16, adding that the priest showed “no fear at all as he made straight for the relics inside the cathedral, and made sure they were saved. He deals with life and death every day and shows no fear.”

Draft of new constitution for Curia reform ready for consultation

A draft of the proposed apostolic constitution for reforming and governing the Roman Curia will soon be sent out to leaders of the world’s bishops’ conferences, religious orders and some pontifical universities for their observations and suggestions.

The draft, which has been approved by Pope Francis’ Council of Cardinals, will be subjected to this “consultative step” before it is once more amended and then given to the Pope for his consideration, Alessandro Gisotti, interim director of the Vatican press office, told reporters on April 10.

The proposed apostolic constitution, provisionally titled “Praedicate Evangelium” (“Preach the Gospel”) also will be sent to the Synods of the Eastern Catholic Churches, the dicasteries of the Roman Curia, the conferences of major superiors of men and women religious and some pontifical universities. They will be asked to send observations and suggestions to the Council of Cardinals so that changes or additions can be made and a final draft be given to the Pope by the end of 2019, Gisotti said.

The Council of Cardinals, which has been advising the Pope on the reform of the Curia and church governance in general, met at the Vatican on April 8-10.

Solutions need to be found with the whole Church, not just Rome

At a visit to La Croix during a Paris conference organized by the German, Swiss and French bishops’ conferences on “The common good in Europe,” Cardinal Reinhard Marx of Munich, a member of Pope Francis’ advisory council of cardinals, reflects on the crisis that the Church is currently experiencing.

“Since Vatican II, we have asked ourselves how the Church should situate itself within a modern, pluralist society where people are free to believe or not that Jesus was raised from the dead and that they can actually meet him.

What we need to imagine is not ‘a new Church’ but a Church that situates itself ‘in another way.’ Catholics themselves have said they want change.

However, this is a slow and painful process. Raising awareness does not occur at the same pace everywhere and some prefer to seek security in the past.

This is reinforced today by a loss of credibility resulting from the revelations of sexual abuse, as well as from a lack of financial transparency and a culture of secrecy.

Pope and Moroccoan King make joint appeal to protect Jerusalem status quo

Pope Francis has signed a joint appeal with Morocco’s King Mohammed VI to protect the status quo of Jerusalem as a place of worship for the followers of the monotheistic faiths. The Holy See has long supported a two-state solution in the Middle East, and supports the international community’s position that Jerusalem is a city of religious and political importance that transcends any one state.

“We consider it important to preserve the Holy City of Jerusalem/Al-Quds Acharif as the common patrimony of humanity and especially the followers of the three monotheistic religions as a place of encounter and as a symbol of peaceful coexistence,” Pope Francis and King Mohammed wrote in their appeal signed in Rabat, 30 March, during Francis’ visit to Morocco.

“To this end, the specific multi-religious character, the spiritual dimension and the particular cultural identity of Jerusalem/Al-Quds Acharif must be protected and promoted.”

The appeal implicitly recognises the international concern about the status of Jerusalem following the President of the United States’ unilateral decision to recognise the city as Israel’s capital, a sore topic for Palestinians who want East Jerusalem as the capital for their future independent state.

From the ashes of genocide, Islam rises in Rwanda

A handful of Muslims took a stand during the hundred days of slaughter. Their stance inspired thousands of Rwandans to become Muslim in what was once called Africa’s most Catholic country. “I was a Catholic pastor before genocide,” Matabaro Sulaiman told TRT World on a chilly in Kigali, dressed in a flashy purple jilbab – a long loose-fit dress worn by Muslim men.

When the genocide in Rwanda began in 1994, the 49-year-old, suffered a crisis of faith watching the churches, in which he preached peace and unity became slaughter houses.

“Christians were killing people in the church,” Sulaiman said.

“The [victims] went to churches thinking they will find peace but instead, they were killed. “Meanwhile, I saw Muslims take people inside the mosque.” Since the advent of European colonialism in the country in 1884, Roman Catholicism has been the dominant religion in Rwanda. But in the last 25 years, Islam has become an alternative for thousands of Rwandans who lost their faith in Christianity during the genocide.

Muslims made up one percent of the population before the genocide. Although no census has been conducted, today “12% to 15% of the total population is Muslim,” according to Salim Habimana, a former Mufti of the country. The 1994 genocide began after a decade-long systematic dehumanisation campaign against the Tutsis turned into full ethnic cleansing. The hatred was so deeply implanted in ordinary society that neighbour turned on neighbour, friend against friend, as people joined the slaughter of those closest to them.

Many went to churches as a last resort to seek refuge but death eventually found them, even in what they hoped were houses of God.

Thousands were killed inside churches across the country, including Rwanda’s largest Catholic Church, Sainte Famille.

More than 2,000 people who sought shelter were killed after Pastor Wenceslas Munyeshyaka collaborated with the attackers instead of protecting those in need.

Archbishop of Canterbury to lead a spiritual retreat at the Vatican

The Archbishop of Canterbury, Justin Welby, was in the Vatican to lead a retreat for civil and ecclesiastical authorities of South Sudan.

Pope Francis has approved the proposal presented by the Archbishop of Canterbury, His Grace Justin Welby, to organise a spiritual retreat to take place in the Vatican, within the Domus Sanctae Marthae, from the 10-11 of this month of April, in which the highest civil and ecclesiastical authorities of South Sudan will participate.

This event, both ecumenical and diplomatic at the same time, was organised by mutual agreement between the Secretariat of State and the Office of the Arch-bishop of Canterbury.

Official Website

Exit mobile version