Catholic Sisters Help Children Living with HIV Build a Better Future
Faith Brings New Hope to Assam Village Once Known for Alcoholism
Cardinal Tagle: Friendship reveals the face of Jesus and the Church
Israel prepares ‘extensive’ West Bank operation after deadly shooting near Tal
Pope: Visit to Türkiye and Lebanon teaches that peace is possible
Thousands protest corruption in Philippines as Church leaders call for accountability
Pope: Nicaea invites Christians to unity in face of violence, conflict
Introduction
Very often we are overly conditioned by the words we use. We must not allow inadequate ways of thinking about the Eucharist to impose the wrong words upon us. At the root of the misunderstanding that is now tearing apart the experience of the Syro-Malabar Church – and also that of other Churches facing the same problem, though less dramatically – lies a rather ambiguous language: it expresses a truth, but not the whole truth. In this reflection, I would like to sketch its history briefly, from which we can learn how to address present-day questions as well.
For many centuries, we distinguished between the “Mass without the people” and the “Mass with the people,” assigning greater value to the former. The former was called “Low Mass” and was very frequent, while the latter was called “Solemn Mass” and was much rarer. The rediscovery, after the Second Vatican Council, of the centrality of the “Mass with the people” required a profound rethinking of the space of celebration and a recovery of the altar’s central position. The change in “orientation” depends on a change in understanding: the Mass is an act of the “priestly community.” Thus, the “side altars” lose their importance and the high altar changes its form. To understand this transition, we must go back many centuries and consider a text that proved decisive.
In his work of 1577, the Archbishop of Milan, Charles Borromeo, identifies several criteria for the construction of churches, including detailed provisions concerning orientation. On the one hand, he prescribes the church’s orientation ad orientem, though with appropriate exceptions. Of the greatest interest, however, is the fact that from that text onward, and in an extraordinarily widespread manner, Catholic churches would have the tabernacle placed upon the altar. This structural element, positioned above the high altar, inevitably determines an orientation “toward the Lord,” represented precisely by this modern structural arrangement. Arising from the reaction against Protestant positions on the Real Presence and sacrifice, the tabernacle assumes a predominantly apologetic role. It also profoundly influences the way in which we orient ourselves in celebration. Let us consider this feature of our churches briefly.
An interesting starting point is the biblical origin of the term “tabernacle,” by which we now identify the place where the Eucharist is reserved and kept. The word comes from the Latin Vulgate, which uses it 473 times: 449 times in the Old Testament and only 24 times in the New Testament. Its primary meaning is “tent.” Its use becomes especially frequent in the Torah, between the Book of Exodus and the Book of Deuteronomy (258 occurrences), precisely when the “dwelling of God” among his people takes the form of a tent or temple. For this reason, the term also occurs widely in the narratives of David and Solomon, in close connection with the building of the temple. It is also used extensively by the prophets, especially Ezekiel, as well as in the Psalms and Wisdom literature. In the New Testament, its use is limited to three major areas of meaning: a tent in the strict sense (for example, in the Synoptic accounts of the Transfiguration); a metaphor for life as pilgrimage (in Paul and Peter); and, finally, reference to the “temple/tabernacle” of the First Testament, especially in Hebrews and Revelation.
The central question concerns where the presence of God is revealed. Israel’s tent/temple as a language of presence led medieval theology, in writings De tabernaculo, to make the allegorical interpretation of the Torah a central theme. This is attested for a millennium, from Bede (seventh–eighth century) to Théophile Raynaud (seventeenth century). The identification of God’s dwelling in the Old Testament with the body of Christ – together with the reading of the temple as Christ’s body and the body as the temple of the Spirit – allowed the theme of the tabernacle to develop over the centuries. It became both a temple of flesh and a heavenly temple, but it also came to assume a location within the domus ecclesiae, almost as a new sancta sanctorum.
In its disciplinary and architectural dimensions, this development tends to leave the Eucharistic rite in the background, treating the “presence of God” solely as the “permanent sacred product of consecration.” It is clear that the modern, Tridentine recovery of the “centrality of the tabernacle” (understood as the “little temple” in which the consecrated bread is reserved in the church), deliberately made a central architectural feature and even placed above the high altar, raises a theological question for us concerning the Eucharistic rite. The progressive separation between the “sacramental Body of Christ” and the “ecclesial Body of Christ” – rather than their being manifested as the inner fabric of the ritual sequence of the Eucharistic celebration – is replaced by “faith in the sacramental body,” which generates devotion and a relationship with the virtues of unity and charity. This leads to concentrating all attention on the “truth of the sacramental body,” while neglecting the ecclesial dimension of the Body of Christ, which cannot be “localized.”
It is very instructive to consider the inertia of the Tridentine model, constructed in the sixteenth century around the central position of the Eucharistic reservation. This model profoundly influences both celebration and Eucharistic theology, which in turn can also be understood as causes and justifications of the central tabernacle. One of the documents closest in time to the Second Vatican Council, and apologetically connected with the liturgical rethinking then taking shape, is the address that Pope Pius XII sent to the International Congress of Liturgy in 1956.
Many observations could be made about this text. I shall limit myself to three:
With a view to renewing Eucharistic theology and the devotion that ritual action can accompany and inspire, these considerations are far from secondary. They show how deeply the one-sided reading of Eucharistic experience, still imposed upon our hearts and bodies by medieval and modern thought, has taken root. An internal rupture within the ritual action can lead one to hold that the breaking of the bread is destined not for consumption in Communion, so as to build up the ecclesial Body of Christ, but for permanence in the tabernacle, so as to preserve the sacramental Body of Christ. To symbolize the Eucharistic reservation as a “tabernacle” (as temple and dwelling) is to replace ecclesial communion with adoration of the sacrament. To recover the tabernacle’s character as simply the place of Eucharistic reservation means, instead, recognizing that consecration is ordered toward consumption, not preservation, and that the rite of Communion should not normally draw from the reserved sacrament, but should always and only proceed from the altar. An excessive symbolization that goes so far as to negate the tabernacle’s function of serving Communion is a matter of no small importance for Eucharistic theology and devotion.
Let us consider the expression that opened the new phase in 1964 and that remains our point of reference today:
Altare exstruatur a pariete seiunctum, ut facile circumiri et in eo celebratio versus populum peragi possit.
“The altar should be built apart from the wall, so that it can easily be walked around and celebration facing the people can take place upon it.”
The expression used immediately after the Council, which we still repeat today, indicates a “tendency” that was then beginning. It uses the words that could best be understood at the time. Yet the phrase “so that celebration toward the people may take place upon it” is an expression that today deserves decisive further reflection.
It is evident that, according to the intention of the text, the missa versus populum and the missa versus altare cannot be regarded as opposing interpretations. Certainly, in post-conciliar debate they acquired symbolic value and became a way of identifying – sometimes in forced terms – two worlds and two forms of celebration and ecclesial life. Here, however, I would like to point out an element that might suggest an “intrinsic” mediation between the two traditions. On closer examination, the language of versus is not at all exclusive, except in the case of the altar. To say versus altare is to exclude versus populum. The reverse is not true. When one says versus populum, one also includes versus altare, because the altar stands “between” the one who presides and the people.
It therefore seems to me that the objections to versus populum – accused of “closing the Church in upon itself” rather than opening it to the transcendence of God (which, it is claimed, would instead be guaranteed by versus altare) – are based on a very weak argument. They overlook the “inclusive” value guaranteed only by versus populum and not by versus altare. Those who face the altar with their backs to the people are obliged to turn around from time to time. Those who face the altar, with the people standing beyond it, experience the reality of the circumstantes: they are simultaneously versus altare and versus populum.
We might therefore say that, theologically, we must move beyond the alternative between two possibilities that was introduced almost surreptitiously through language that was still approximate. The post-conciliar rediscovery of the missa versus populum does not come at the expense of the altar; rather, it recovers the need to unite, in a single act, the twofold but non-contradictory orientation toward the altar and toward the people. If the altar can be “surrounded” by the act of worship, orientation toward the altar and orientation toward the people can occur in the same act. By contrast, when the minister and the entire assembly are oriented “toward an altar that is not detached from the wall,” a different situation arises, continually introducing the need for an intermittent “reorientation versus populum.”
This linguistic difficulty calls for a new way of speaking and thinking.
What is the central point of the Eucharistic celebration?
To answer this question, it is not helpful to create a polarization between altar and people. It is not helpful to create a tension between sacrament and Church. It is not helpful to create a tension between consecration and Communion.
Here, then, is the central point of our question:
The “people,” toward whom the celebration is oriented, are not a distraction from the sacrament, but the fulfilment of the mystery, the destination of the Paschal event. Every Mass is fulfilled in the movement from East, to Altar, to People. There can therefore be no contradiction: one may begin facing East; one must honour the altar; one must listen to the Word while facing the ambo; and one stands as the circumstantes around the altar. Thus, toward the altar and toward the people are one and the same, precisely because the Body of Christ – as sacrament and as Church – is one and the same.
Dividing the Mass into a part toward the people and a part toward the altar is a serious distortion. Although it seeks to find a point of mediation, it risks creating a stalemate and preventing the Church’s consciousness from maturing. This is all the more true because the movement cannot be “from the people to the altar,” but, if anything, “from the altar to the people.” “Toward the people” concerns not primarily the proclamation of the Word, but the rite of Communion.
The ultimate meaning of the Eucharist is the ecclesial Body of Christ. We must not only think of the Eucharist as oriented “toward the people”; we must also recognize the “assembled people,” who acknowledge themselves as the Body of the Risen One, as Eucharist.
In the end, using the beautiful words of St Augustine from a Pentecost homily, we may say: Estote quod videtis, accipite quod estis – “Be what you see; receive what you are.” If this is the truth of the Eucharistic rite, the bitter disputes over orientation appear increasingly to be forms of resistance to the Second Vatican Council and questions that are essentially “rearguard” concerns.
[1] Professor of Sacramental Theology at the Faculty of Theology of the Pontifical Athenum of St. Anselm in Rome. This is a shorter version of a paper presented at the International Symposium on Eucharistic Celebration and Community Participation held at Niveditha, Aluva 0n 24-25 July 2026
Leave a Comment