Reflections on Modi’s Friend Donald

Sathyadeepam Weekly
  • Dr. Valson Thampu

The predictable, but incredible, has happened. Trump has been trimmed down to the telluric. Had he been a little more educated, he would have known that history is the art of reducing boisterous bullies to silent footnotes. At the time of writing this, the GOP has lost control of the Senate and the Congress; and Trump begun to flaunt ‘Veto’ to cap his defiance. If not in the US, at least in India Trump has a grieving friend.

Perhaps what Modi would note with particular anxiety is how the Gen Z in the US has trumped Trump. Only 10% of the US electorate belong to this category. But there was a swing in excess of 40% in their votes against the Republicans. The consequence is there for all to see. This cannot be particularly soothing for Modi, as 28% of India’s voters will be in the Gen Z voter category (18-29 age group) by 2029 – nearly three times the Gen Z chunk in the US elections. The Gen Z voters scorn sentimentality, mock hero-worship, and reject mendacious propaganda flourishes, predicated on the stupidity of the common man.

The Gen Z are implacably rooted in the realities of their life-world. They will not say that all is well with them, when there is nothing going for them, just to oblige someone who assumes that they are mere fodder for his brand of hotch-potch politics. They care more for jobs, more for education, and less for andh bhakti. They ask uncomfortable questions. Try and exhort them to think for the country, and not for themselves! They will retort: ‘Look at you!’

Another lesson that Modi might learn from the Trump tragi-comedy is, it is counterproductive to exceed the limits. The society has its ethical range. There’s a limit to how far you can go. Crossing the Lakshman rekha, is disastrous. This realization is deeply rooted in our civilizational ethos. Lord Ram is maryada Purushottam. ‘Maryada’ means keeping oneself strictly within limits. Over-play your boorishness and cynical unconcern for the people; and you’ll provoke a tsunamic reaction.

Here’s the image that came to mind as I mulled over Trump’s present plight. Given the dynamics of democracy, the mega-MAGA neta standing there like a colossus is no more than an inflated balloon. Not far from he stands the common man with a pump in one hand and a needle in the other. Their uses are seasonal. When the season comes, it is up to him to decide what to use. Last time he chose to inflate the balloon. This time, the needle. Just a prick. The balloon goes phut! Some shredded pieces of latex remain. We call this democracy.

W.H. Hudson illustrate the alchemy of Shakespeare’s art. All of Shakespeare’s characters were borrowed. But the raw material he derived from various sources and the final products there is a magical transformation. Hudson offers a comparison- Children late in the evening see glow-worms glittering on the landscape. They think they are diamonds and decide to come back the next morning with baskets big enough to gather all of the diamonds. They return, only to find ugly worms crawling away.

The truth is that the glow is an illusion, or maya, if you like. But power has an uncanny knack to lure its megalomaniac addicts into blunder-lands of delusions. They begin to give themselves airs of divinity, which betokens, unbeknown to them, deep-seated anxiety about the Chair vanishing like in a nightmare. This anxiety is like no ordinary anxiety. It can be mitigated only by delusions of divinity. If you are a god, the seat is yours forever. Some boast they are gods; others behave as if they are no less. That’s the only difference.

Trump is the infection that the Americans brought upon themselves, using their freedom of choice. To an extent at least, he mirrors America as it is today. Clipping his wings with the punitive power of votes is a small task. The real task is to become the sort of people who merit a better leader. You got to be kidding, if you think that you can make America great again by handing the country over to a selfish bully for whom everything, including a Nobel Peace Prize is a matter of deals.

There’s something in this for India as well. To get a clue, just consider the SIR. Do you think that in a normative democracy, an election commissioner would have dared to bump off 13.2 crores citizens from the electoral list to favor a party? What is even more shocking is that it is made so very hard to undo the harm, even after it is fully exposed. Even volcanic expressions of people’s resentment fail to yield the desired result. The aplomb with which this anti-people atrocity is justified in public by the custodians of the party that hopes to benefit from it pushes us to the very brink of the precipice.

Sodom and Gomorrah are not old wives’ tales. They are parabolic reminders that when the tolerable moral range is exceed, human justice fails, and the poor are orphaned, poetic justice will kick in for sure. ‘Who brought down Napoleon?’ Victor Hugo asks in Les Miserable.” Hugo argues that Napoleon had become too big for history. “The excessive weight of this man in human destiny disturbed the balance.” And history brooks no disequilibrium.

Leave a Comment

*
*