Catholic Sisters Help Children Living with HIV Build a Better Future
Faith Brings New Hope to Assam Village Once Known for Alcoholism
Cardinal Tagle: Friendship reveals the face of Jesus and the Church
Israel prepares ‘extensive’ West Bank operation after deadly shooting near Tal
Pope: Visit to Türkiye and Lebanon teaches that peace is possible
Thousands protest corruption in Philippines as Church leaders call for accountability
Pope: Nicaea invites Christians to unity in face of violence, conflict
The Kerala High Court has directed the State Government to constitute a fresh and independent expert committee to investigate allegations of coastal erosion linked to the Vizhinjam International Seaport project. The court also declared the constitution of the previous expert committee flawed and ruled that its report should not be acted upon.
Justice Harisankar V. Menon issued the order while considering a petition filed by residents of fishing villages situated within 20 kilometres north of Vizhinjam. The petitioners alleged that the construction of the seaport, particularly its breakwaters, had contributed to coastal erosion along the northern coastline and the accumulation of sand on the southern side. They also raised concerns about damage to houses and the impact on the traditional livelihoods of fishing communities.
The petitioners challenged the expert committee appointed by the State Government in October 2022 to examine the allegations. They questioned the impartiality of certain members, pointing to their previous professional associations with the port project and related organisations.
The court found substance in the concerns regarding potential conflicts of interest. In particular, it observed that M. D. Kudale, who chaired the committee, had previously served as an expert member of a technical sub-committee involved in the development of the Vizhinjam port. The court also considered allegations concerning another member’s professional association with a company connected to the project.
However, the court clarified that it was not examining the scientific correctness of the committee’s conclusions. Its consideration was confined to the legality of the committee’s constitution and the validity of its report.
The State Government had maintained that coastal erosion in the region could be attributed to natural factors, including high wave activity and cyclonic conditions, rather than port construction. The port authorities and project concessionaire also defended the project, citing its strategic importance and the environmental clearances obtained.
The High Court clarified that the petition did not seek a halt to the ongoing construction of the port. Instead, it focused on ensuring an impartial investigation into the coastal concerns raised by residents.
The new committee must comprise independent experts without conflicts of interest and undertake the studies envisaged in the original government order. The court also directed the government to consider the observations in its judgment and the views of relevant stakeholders.
The ruling brings renewed attention to the concerns of coastal communities and highlights the importance of independent environmental assessment. It also underlines the need to balance infrastructure development with environmental protection and the livelihood security of fishing families.
Leave a Comment